Stated Supply Pastor

Rev. Michelle Henrichs

  Send Email

As well as her part-time contract with Heritage, Rev. Michelle Henrichs currently pastors Withness Community, a New Worshipping Community in the Milwaukee Presbytery.

She graduated with honors from McCormick Theological Seminary in May 2013. Michelle has been married to her husband, Dave for 20 years and they have two teenage sons. She enjoys playing games and watching movies with her family, reading, running, cycling and yoga. You can find out more about her at 

Music Team Leader

Connie Fellows

Connie has been a youth leader, musician, arranger and special services coordinator at Heritage for more then 20 years. Starting fall 2017 she will be leading the music team coordinating all of our services.

Connie teaches middle school band at St. Anthony on the Lake School in Pewaukee, Holy Apostles School in New Berlin and St. Jerome School in Oconomowoc. She enjoys performing as much as possible, including playing her trumpet in a few concerts each year with the Green Bay Symphony Orchestra. 

Connie is married to Michael Krofta, the Band Director at Oconomowoc High School. They have two adult children, Ryan and Erin.

Pianist and Office Secretary

Heidi Surprenant

  Send Email

Heidi Surprenant is a musician, author and educator from New Berlin, Wisconsin. She teaches music theory at Alverno College in Milwaukee and serves as the organist/pianist for Heritage Presbyterian and Bethel Lutheran in Muskego. Together, Heidi and her husband Mike raised four amazing children, now grown and lovingly launched into the world.


Susan Fellows

  Send Email

Clerk of Session

Glenn Sheridan

  Send Email

Contact Us

Heritage Church

  • (Tudor Oaks Senior Living Center)
    S77W12929 Mc Shane Dr.
    Muskego, Wisconsin 53150
  • Map
  • Phone 414-425-2050
  • Email
  • Facebook
Summer Schedule

Office Hours

  • Wednesdays/Thursdays/Fridays 1-4 PM


  • Wired Word Adult Study (study on your own)
  • Live Worship on the Patio and via ZOOM
    – 10:00 AM to 10:40 AM
  • Fellowship Time Live and via ZOOM
    – 10:40 AM
Contents © 2021 Heritage Presbyterian Church • Church Website Builder by mychurchwebsite.netPrivacy Policy